Science to understand a changing world.
RSS
Research Article

How to define objectives, audiences, and success criteria before communicating science

A guide to deciding what you want to achieve, with whom, and how to evaluate scientific communication before choosing the message, format, or channel.

Yellow and black dartboard with several darts stuck in different areas of the board.Contextual image

Key ideas

  • First define whether the communication aims to share information, foster understanding, hear perspectives, or influence decisions; each purpose calls for a different approach.
  • Get to know the specific audience—their questions, interests, prior knowledge, and barriers to access—without treating demographic categories as stereotypes.
  • Relate observations to the objective and distinguish what was observed from what can be concluded; the sources do not establish a universal indicator of success.

Start with the purpose, not the format

Before preparing a talk, a publication, or an activity, specify the purpose of the communication. It may be to share results, foster understanding of a topic, hear perspectives and concerns, or influence opinions, behaviors, or policy preferences. These objectives are not interchangeable: each requires different decisions about what to communicate and how. The National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine defines science communication as an exchange of information and viewpoints about science to achieve objectives, including increasing understanding or learning more about public perspectives and concerns. It is therefore not limited to transmitting information in one direction (National Academies, 2017 report summary).

State the objective as a specific and feasible intention. For example: “explain the general results of a research study to a school group” or “start a conversation with residents to learn what questions they have about a research study.” These are hypothetical planning examples, not demonstrated results or promises of an effect.

It is useful to distinguish between sharing information, fostering understanding, engaging in dialogue, and influencing an action or decision. If the goal is to listen, a session with time for questions may be more appropriate than a one-way presentation. If the goal is to explain, you will need to decide which ideas are essential and what level of detail is appropriate. And if an action is expected, consider whether communication alone can contribute to it: decisions also depend on needs, knowledge, skills, values, and other circumstances. More information, or a clearer presentation, does not by itself guarantee a change in opinion or behavior (National Academies, chapter 1).

Define whom you want to reach or hear from

“Non-specialist audience” does not describe a uniform group. Before writing, identify whom you need to reach or hear from and what role that audience would play in relation to the objective. Ask yourself what they might already know, what interests them, what questions or concerns they may have, and what barriers could make access or participation difficult.

These questions are intended to help investigate the context, not to assign characteristics to people based on their age, place of residence, or another demographic category. Avoid assuming that everyone in a group thinks alike. Experiences, priorities, prior knowledge, and cultural contexts can influence how communication is received; adapting the approach therefore requires paying attention to the specific audience rather than relying on stereotypes (COMPASS, audience guidance).

Also consider what the activity may ask of the audience: is it enough to access an explanation? Are they expected to ask questions? Are they invited to share knowledge or perspectives? Is there a specific action they can take? Stating these expectations in advance helps prevent a listening activity from being evaluated as if its purpose were to teach, or attendance at a talk from being interpreted as proof of understanding.

Choose the approach and channel afterward

Once the objective and audience are defined, connect those decisions to the central message, language, format, channel, and available resources. The channel influences the form the message can take: a meeting, a podcast, and a presentation offer different ways to participate and call for different approaches. It is useful to start with where the audience can be reached and which formats are accessible and feasible, rather than automatically choosing the communicator’s favorite channel (COMPASS, guidance on platforms and tactics).

The plan also needs to fit the actual capacity to carry it out. You do not need to be everywhere: time, financial resources, available expertise, and possible collaborations limit which channels can be maintained. A format chosen for its appeal may be poorly suited if it does not serve the purpose or makes it difficult for the audience to participate.

Before producing materials, check for consistency: does the message address the objective? Does the format allow for the interaction sought? Is the channel accessible to the people it is intended for? Are there enough resources to carry out the activity? If the answer to any of these questions is no, adjust the plan before developing the content.

Evaluate what the plan makes possible to observe

The National Academies notes that science communication can pursue different objectives and that approaches should align with those objectives. It also cautions that information alone may not be enough to achieve goals such as influencing decisions or behaviors; people consider their needs, knowledge, skills, values, and beliefs. The report also identifies gaps in knowledge about how science communication relates to broader outcomes. Therefore, when assessing an activity, it is useful to distinguish between what was done, what was observed, and what can be concluded; the available documentation does not establish a universal evaluation formula or a single indicator of success (National Academies, 2017 report summary).

As part of the plan, you can specify which observations would be relevant to the objective: for example, what questions come up in a conversation, or what perspectives the audience shares when the purpose is to listen. This describes information that could be collected; it does not, by itself, validate a measure of understanding or demonstrate that communication caused a change. The method and context determine what interpretation is reasonable.

Two hypothetical planning examples

In a school context, a researcher could aim to explain their own research study to a group without presuming what the students know. They could open the floor to questions and record what questions arise. These observations would make it possible to describe the interaction in that activity, but would not, by themselves, be enough to establish how much each person understood or whether there was a lasting effect.

For a general audience, a science communicator could organize a conversation to share the same research study and learn what aspects spark interest or concern. They could record the questions and perspectives expressed in relation to their listening goal. In both cases, the examples are hypothetical: they do not describe actual experiments or results.

Objective Audience to reach or hear from Communication activity Possible channel Observation related to the objective
Foster understanding of a central idea School group, taking account of their questions and prior knowledge Explain one’s own research study and open the floor to questions In-person activity or format accessible to the group Questions asked during the activity; these alone are not equivalent to a validated measure of understanding
Hear interests and concerns People in a community interested in the research Briefly introduce the topic and facilitate a conversation Meeting or conversation in a space appropriate for the audience Questions and perspectives expressed in relation to the purpose of listening

A brief checklist before preparing the message

  • What do I want to achieve: share information, foster understanding, engage in dialogue, or influence an action or decision?
  • Whom do I want to reach or hear from, and what do I need to find out about their interests, questions, and barriers to access?
  • Which observations would be relevant to the objective, and what would they—or would they not—allow me to conclude?
  • What message, language, and format fit the audience and purpose?
  • Which channel can I sustain with the available resources and make accessible?
  • What data do I actually need to describe the activity and how it was received?
  • What will I change next time if the observations do not address the objective?

Planning this way does not turn communication into a universal formula. Its value lies in making decisions explicit and adapting the activity based on what is learned, without claiming more for an observation than it can support.

COMPASS guidance is presented here as methodological context, not as independent corroboration of the findings in the National Academies report.

What we know and its limits

Science communication depends on diverse objectives, audiences, and contexts. The National Academies notes that information alone does not guarantee changes in opinion or behavior and that there are gaps in knowledge about the relationship between communication and broader outcomes. The sources provided do not establish a universal method for evaluating success criteria or allow causality to be attributed to observations from an activity.

Original sources4

The original sources for exploring this explanation and its limits.

  1. Communicating Science Effectively: A Research Agenda (2017) — Summary National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine
    Informe de síntesis metodológica publicado en2017; pasaje consultado y conservado para una guía original, sin presentarlo como noticia ni ensayo.
  2. Using Science to Improve Science Communication — Communicating Science Effectively: A Research Agenda (2017), chapter 1 National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine
    Informe de síntesis metodológica publicado en2017; pasaje consultado y conservado para una guía original, sin presentarlo como noticia ni ensayo.
  3. FAQ: How Do I Change My Messaging for Different Audiences? COMPASS Science Communication
    Orientaciones de primera parte de COMPASS sobre comunicación científica; referencia metodológica, no ensayo independiente.
  4. Finding the Right Fit: Where and How to Share Your Message COMPASS Science Communication
    Orientaciones de primera parte de COMPASS sobre comunicación científica; referencia metodológica, no ensayo independiente.
Image credits

Vibrant darts stuck in a yellow and black dartboard representing precision and strategy. · Photo by RDNE Stock project on Pexels · Original source · Pexels License · Resized and re-encoded as JPEG; full framing preserved.

The SciClue Editorial Team is responsible for creating and publishing this content. AI supports information gathering, source research and drafting within an editorial process that includes source and consistency checks.
Have you found something we should correct?
Explore all concepts

Put it into practice

Energy use calculator Wave laboratory Probability laboratory

Every discovery starts with a question.

Articles, concepts, technologies and indicators. All connected.

Energy Physics Concepts Tools