Science to understand a changing world.
RSS
Research Article

Science teacher training: integrating technology with a pedagogical purpose

Educational technology makes sense when it is linked to learning objectives and evidence of understanding. DigCompEdu offers a framework to guide this choice, the design of activities, and reflection on its limitations.

Screenshot of the PhET Circuit Construction Kit interactive simulation showing a simple electrical circuit with a battery, light bulb, and electron current.Contextual image

Key ideas

  • DigCompEdu and TPACK help guide resource selection and instructional design by relating objectives, pedagogy, technology, and content; they do not guarantee the effectiveness of a tool.
  • Simulations, virtual laboratories, and sensors can support inquiry activities, but their models and measurements have limitations; the proposed classroom activities are not measured efficacy outcomes.
  • Teacher training can incorporate practice, feedback, and support, together with planning for accessibility, privacy, security, connectivity, and cost; the cited sources do not prove universal efficacy.

The pedagogical purpose comes before the tool

The European Framework for the Digital Competence of Educators (DigCompEdu), developed by the European Commission — Joint Research Centre (JRC), organizes educators’ digital competence into areas that include professional engagement, digital resources, teaching and learning, assessment, and empowering learners. The framework guides decisions such as selecting or creating resources according to the objective, context, pedagogical approach, and characteristics of the group; protecting content and data; and analyzing evidence of learning. It is a professional reference, not a trial of an application or proof that incorporating technology by itself improves learning (DigCompEdu, European Commission — JRC).

The TPACK framework complements this perspective by linking technological, pedagogical, and disciplinary knowledge. Knowing how to use a tool is not enough: how it is taught and which scientific concept is addressed also matter. Both frameworks help inform teaching decisions, but they do not guarantee the effectiveness of a tool or activity.

In practice, it is useful to first define which scientific concept is to be taught, what difficulty might arise, and what performance would demonstrate understanding. One can then choose among a simulation, a virtual laboratory, sensors, or non-digital materials. The question is not whether a tool is novel, but whether it helps achieve the objective and makes it possible to observe learners’ reasoning. DigCompEdu also includes accessibility, differentiation, and active participation: teaching competence is not limited to technical proficiency with the resource.

A 2026 systematic review on digital competence in physics teaching, based on searches in Scopus and publications in English, brings together studies with heterogeneous designs. It describes the potential of simulations and virtual laboratories when aligned with pedagogical purposes, but cautions that perceptions, self-assessments, or expert validations are not enough to demonstrate improvements in learning. The review provides context about the field; it does not estimate a universal effect, and its conclusions do not automatically extend to all sciences and levels (review on digital competence in physics education).

Designing activities that make it possible to examine reasoning

An inquiry sequence can start with a question, ask for a prediction, vary one condition while keeping others constant, record observations, and justify an explanation. A digital resource can help explore a phenomenon, but interaction alone does not constitute inquiry. To examine learning, what matters is what the student can explain or do, not just whether they completed an action on screen.

The table presents adaptable classroom proposals, not activities whose pedagogical effectiveness has been proven. In each case, the objective and expected output guide the use of the tool; if it is unavailable, an alternative is proposed that preserves an analysis task.

Objective Possible resource Activity Evidence to examine Alternative if the resource is unavailable
Analyze how current changes when resistance is varied while the source remains constant. PhET simulation Circuit Construction Kit: DC. Predict, build, and test the virtual circuit; record the variables and justify the conclusion. An explanation linking variables, tests, and model limitations, not just a screenshot. Analyze tabulated data on paper or, if appropriate and safe, work with a physical circuit and suitable materials.
Compare light readings under different conditions. phyphox Light experiment on a compatible device. Keep the position and, as far as possible, background light stable; change one condition, repeat, and represent the data using the units shown by the sensor. A table or graph and an explanation of the variation and measurement limitations. Use environmental data collected previously by the teacher, identifying their source, on paper or in a spreadsheet.
Anticipate a procedure and identify variables and controls. A virtual laboratory model available in the educational context. Predict and justify decisions within the model; then explain which aspects of the procedure it does not represent. A comparative explanation of the model and the procedure. An accessible sequence on paper or a teacher demonstration, depending on the context.
Distinguish observation from inference when interpreting data. Printed tables or graphs. Formulate a question, compare variables, and decide whether the data support an explanation or whether more observations are needed. An interpretation that identifies the relevant data and distinguishes what was observed from what was inferred. The same printed table; when needed, accompany it with a textual description of the graph.

In the circuit activity, PhET makes it possible to explore direct-current circuits, components, and current and voltage measurements. Comparing the model with a real setup can help discuss what it represents and what it does not: the simulation does not by itself reproduce contact errors or variations in physical equipment. Any hands-on activity requires suitable materials and the school’s safety rules; the setup must never be connected to the mains. This proposal does not provide measured learning outcomes (Circuit Construction Kit: DC documentation).

Virtual laboratories, measurements, and practical experiences

A virtual laboratory can help anticipate procedures and make variables and controls visible before an activity. Learners can predict what would change, justify what should be kept constant, and then compare the model with a real experiment when appropriate. The model can support visualization and preparation, but it does not automatically train handling, manual dexterity, or responses to equipment errors or physical safety conditions. If the objective includes those experiences, the virtual activity does not replace hands-on practice or teacher guidance.

In the light example, the phyphox page warns that the ambient sensor is not available to the application on iPhone. It is therefore useful to check device compatibility before designing the activity, rather than assuming that all phones will work. A sensor reading is also not automatically equivalent to a calibrated measurement of solar power: illuminance and irradiance are different quantities. An instrumental study of phone light sensors addresses calibration and uncertainty in measuring solar irradiance; it provides context on measurement, not evidence of the educational effectiveness of the proposed activity (phyphox Light experiment; instrumental study of phone light sensors).

If offline use is needed, check the current documentation to see whether the specific PhET option selected allows it, with what compatibility and under what conditions; do not assume all versions or features are available. phyphox allows measurements to be saved and exported; when transferring them to a spreadsheet, units and context must be retained. Testing resources on the available devices and preparing a paper alternative helps plan for continuity, although the alternative is not identical to manipulating the simulator (offline access to PhET; phyphox frequently asked questions).

Training to design, rehearse, and review

A brief technical session on an application’s controls does not, by itself, constitute professional development. The Education Endowment Foundation (EEF) professional development guidance describes mechanisms such as modeling, practical rehearsal, feedback, social support, and follow-up to consolidate the application of learning. Based on this framework, a proposal for future teachers could include exploring a resource as a learner, designing an activity, rehearsing it through peer microteaching, receiving feedback, and reviewing the work produced when implementing it with a mentor’s support. Time and institutional support are also needed to make rehearsal and review possible.

The EEF guidance refers to practicing teachers, so applying its mechanisms to initial teacher education is an adaptation, not a sequence validated for that group. A 2024 study, based on focus groups with advanced secondary-level preservice teachers at a European university, describes perceptions that self-directed learning can help develop skills and that collaboration and guidance are also desired for teaching digital skills professionally. It includes different subjects and does not measure a causal improvement in student learning. It provides context about expressed needs, not proof that a particular training format works for all future teachers (EEF professional development guidance; study of preservice teachers’ perceptions).

When reviewing an activity, one can ask whether the instructions helped formulate a prediction, whether the records retained units, whether the explanation distinguished evidence from inference, and whether there were access barriers. These questions help improve the design, but they do not in themselves constitute a causal evaluation of the technology.

Inclusion, privacy, and conditions of use

Accessibility is planned alongside the activity. CAST’s Universal Design for Learning Guidelines propose multiple means of engagement, representation, and action and expression. In a data interpretation task, for example, one can provide a table alongside the graph and allow an oral or written explanation. Depending on the group’s needs and the characteristics of the resource, it is useful to check keyboard operation, contrast, magnification, screen-reader compatibility, and textual or audio alternatives. One should not assume that every simulation offers the same options or that an adaptation by itself guarantees accessibility (CAST Universal Design for Learning Guidelines).

Technology should not make a personal phone a requirement. School devices, shared work, or a paper alternative can be provided. For applications and platforms, the school must know what data are collected, what permissions are requested, who can access the information, where and for how long it is retained, and how it is deleted. Identifiable work or data should not be uploaded to unauthorized services; files should be shared through approved channels. The Spanish Data Protection Agency’s guidance provides contextual information for schools in Spain and is marked under review; it is not a universal rule and does not replace checking the conditions applicable at each school (AEPD guidance for schools).

The total cost must also be considered: equipment, operation, maintenance, connectivity, and training, in addition to the initial license. The recommendations in UNESCO’s 2023 GEM Report suggest considering relevance, equity, sustainability, and independent evidence, taking the needs of learners and teachers into account. When assessing evidence about a technology, it is useful to examine the methods, sample, measures, possible biases, funding or provider interests, and relevance to the context. These are recommendations to guide decisions, not a guarantee that every resource is free or suitable in every context (recommendations in UNESCO’s 2023 GEM Report).

Evaluating with caution

Before implementing a proposal, one can agree on what scientific outcome is expected and what evidence would demonstrate it. Initial and subsequent explanations, a transfer task involving another case, and reviewing student work can help examine reasoning. It may also be useful, when feasible, to compare with a reasonable alternative. Prior knowledge, time, teacher support, and access barriers matter when interpreting results.

Satisfaction, reported motivation, or screen time do not, by themselves, amount to scientific learning. A before-and-after comparison in a single group also does not show that any difference is due to the tool. Attributing changes to the resource would require learning outcomes, appropriate comparisons, and attention to design limitations; an association or favorable perception does not demonstrate causality.

The cited materials serve different purposes. DigCompEdu and TPACK are guiding frameworks; CAST’s guidelines and UNESCO’s recommendations inform design; the study of future teachers reports perceptions; the sensor study concerns measurement; and the review on physics education synthesizes studies with heterogeneous methods. None of these materials, on its own, demonstrates that a simulation, sensor, or training format improves learning in every classroom. A defensible pedagogical decision links the resource to a clear objective, collects relevant evidence, and recognizes the limitations of the context and measurement.

Two worksheets for developing the examples in class

The following worksheets are original planning proposals, not sequences whose effectiveness has been measured. Teachers can adjust their duration, support, and difficulty to suit the group. The questions and tables are for preparing the activity and recording observations, not for certifying learning or the operation of all devices.

Circuit worksheet: predict, build, and explain

Proposed level: secondary, after working on what voltage, current, and resistance represent. Reasoning objective: relate a prediction to the readings obtained in a model and justify which variable was changed. Materials: a school device with Circuit Construction Kit: DC, its documentation, and a recording sheet. As an indicative, author-created allocation, 45 minutes can be set aside for preparation, exploration, and discussion; this is not a duration prescribed or evaluated by PhET.

The simulation makes it possible to build circuits from diagrams and use an ammeter and voltmeter. Its objectives include explaining relationships in series and parallel circuits. These features make it possible to propose the activity; they do not by themselves demonstrate improved learning.

  1. Before opening the model, the teacher poses a question about a simple circuit and asks for a reasoned prediction. For example: what current reading do you expect if you change one resistor while keeping the source constant?
  2. The group builds the diagram in the simulation and identifies which component and reading correspond to the question. The teacher checks beforehand that the available version and controls allow this task.
  3. An initial configuration is recorded. One selected variable is changed and what is observed is recorded again, using the units shown by the model. Predicted results are not filled in as if they were measurements.
  4. The prediction is compared with both configurations, and an explanation is given of what the readings support and what remains unverified. If differences appear, the connections and parameters are checked before attributing a cause to them.
  5. The conclusion distinguishes what this model shows from a hands-on activity with physical components. This worksheet does not propose building a real circuit or connecting it to the mains.
Configuration What remains constant What is changed Reading and unit Prediction and explanation
Initial To be completed To be completed To be recorded To be reasoned out
Comparison To be completed To be completed To be recorded To be compared

Proposed assessment question: What specific comparison supports your explanation, and what change in the variable would prevent you from attributing the result to it? The teacher can collect a written or oral response, or an explained diagram. If the equipment or connection does not allow the simulation, the teacher can provide a diagram and prepared data, identified as such; this alternative supports reasoning about data without being presented as the same interactive experience.

Light worksheet: record variation without confusing quantities

Proposed level: secondary, involving reading tables and distinguishing a variable from a measurement condition. Objective: describe how a reading changes and recognize the sensor’s limitations. Materials: a compatible school device with phyphox’s Light experiment, a recording sheet, and ordinary lighting conditions. As an adaptable proposal, one 45-minute session can be devoted to it; this is also not a duration validated by the resource.

Light provides data from the phone’s ambient light sensor. That sensor is not accessible to applications on iPhone, even if the device has one for adjusting screen brightness. Therefore, the equipment must be checked before planning the measurement. An illuminance reading is not, by itself, a measurement of solar irradiance.

  1. The teacher checks the sensor and its operation on the available device. The activity does not require every student to provide a phone or install an application.
  2. A simple comparison of ambient light is defined, keeping the device’s position and orientation constant when those are not the selected variables. The changed condition is noted.
  3. Several readings are recorded for each condition, along with the indicated unit. Any variation during recording is also described, without inventing precision or calibration for the sensor.
  4. The information is represented or compared without automatically converting it into another physical quantity. The recorded data are distinguished from their interpretation.
  5. Students are asked what conditions could explain differences between repetitions and what would need to be controlled to compare them better.
Condition Position and orientation Repetition Reading and unit Observed variation
Initial To be described To be recorded To be recorded To be described
Comparison To be described To be recorded To be recorded To be described

The measurement can be taken by a teacher for the whole group. If a compatible device is unavailable, prepared data are used and their source is stated; readings attributed to students are not invented. This proposal does not require enabling remote access or the microphone, taking photographs of students, or collecting identifiers. The paper alternative preserves the interpretation task, though not the handling of the sensor.

Proposed assessment question: Which part of your conclusion corresponds to the readings, and which part depends on conditions you have not controlled? A table accompanied by a textual description makes it possible to work without relying solely on the color of a graph.

Directory for preparing these two worksheets

Institution or project Resource Reference language Use in these proposals
University of Colorado Boulder Circuit Construction Kit: DC English Building and reading simulated circuits; check requirements and controls beforehand.
RWTH Aachen University, phyphox Light and frequently asked questions English Ambient light sensor, access limitations, and data recording.
CAST UDL Guidelines 3.0 English Design questions about engagement, representation, and response options.

The documentary research for this addition was conducted on November 15, 2026. This does not certify all features, licenses, prices, or offline capabilities of each installation. Before class, the school should check access and the conditions of the version it intends to use. The materials above are original preparation guides; the linked documents retain their authorship and terms. )

What we know and its limits

DigCompEdu and TPACK are guiding frameworks, not efficacy trials. The review on digital competence is limited to physics teaching, publications in English indexed in Scopus, and heterogeneous designs; it does not allow for a quantitative synthesis or demonstrate universal causal effects. The study of future teachers describes perceptions, includes different subjects, and does not measure causal effects on learning; the EEF guide concerns practicing teachers, so applying it to initial teacher training is an adaptation. The sensor study is instrumental, not pedagogical. The proposed activities are adaptable examples, not interventions with demonstrated efficacy. The AEPD guide is Spanish contextual guidance and is under review.

Original sources12

The original sources for exploring this explanation and its limits.

  1. European Framework for the Digital Competence of Educators: DigCompEdu European Commission — Joint Research Centre · 10.2760/159770
    Digital competence framework for teachers: resources, teaching, assessment, inclusion, and professional development.
  2. A systematic review of digital competence in physics education in the era of industry 4.0 Discover Education — Nurazmi and Bancong · 10.1007/s44217-026-02294-z
    A 2026 review of digital competence in physics education and the conditions for meaningfully integrating technologies.
  3. Pre-Service Teachers’ Perceptions of Their Digital Competencies and Ways to Acquire Those through Their Studies and Self-Organized Learning Education Sciences — Göltl, Ambros, Dolezal and Motschnig · 10.3390/educsci14090951
    A 2024 study on the perceptions of prospective secondary school teachers and their need for supported training.
  4. Circuit Construction Kit: DC PhET Interactive Simulations — University of Colorado Boulder
    A direct-current electrical circuit simulation for exploring models and testing predictions.
  5. Light — ambient light sensor experiment phyphox — RWTH Aachen University
    Documentation for the Light experiment and its compatibility limitations with light sensors.
  6. Smartphone Light Sensors as an Innovative Tool for Solar Irradiance Measurements Sensors — Di Laccio and colleagues · 10.3390/s24217051
    An instrumental study from 2024: calibration and limitations when using phone light sensors.
  7. Effective Professional Development — Guidance Report Education Endowment Foundation — Joe Collin and Ellen Smith
    An evidence-review-based guide to continuing professional development: modeling, practice, feedback, and contextual application.
  8. CAST Universal Design for Learning Guidelines 3.0 CAST
    Universal design guidelines for offering diverse ways to engage, represent information, and express learning.
  9. Technology in education: A tool on whose terms? — Recommendations UNESCO Global Education Monitoring Report
    GEM 2023 recommendations: objectives, equity, independent evidence, sustainability, and data protection.
  10. Guide for educational institutions — privacy and platforms Agencia Española de Protección de Datos
    Guidance from the Spanish authority on applications, privacy, and the responsible use of school data.
  11. Offline access to PhET simulations PhET Interactive Simulations — University of Colorado Boulder
    Official offline-use options and conditions to check when planning activities.
  12. Frequently Asked Questions — phyphox phyphox — RWTH Aachen University
    Documentation on sensor availability, saving, and exporting measurements.
Image credits

PhET Interactive Simulations — PhET Circuit Construction Kit screenshot · PhET, screenshot by Dudhhr · Wikimedia Commons · CC BY 4.0 · Original source · CC BY 4.0 · Resized and re-encoded as JPEG; full framing preserved.

The SciClue Editorial Team is responsible for creating and publishing this content. AI supports information gathering, source research and drafting within an editorial process that includes source and consistency checks.
Have you found something we should correct?
Explore all concepts

Put it into practice

Energy use calculator Wave laboratory Probability laboratory

Every discovery starts with a question.

Articles, concepts, technologies and indicators. All connected.

Energy Physics Concepts Tools